STScI Logo
STScI Logo
HST
Banner

A User's Guide to the differences between numarray and Numeric.

For the most part, one can use the existing Numeric manual as a manual for numarray (we are in the process of editing the Numeric manual for use with numarray). The following should be read to understand what differences there are between numarray and Numeric. The emphasis is given to differences between common capabilities; at the end, there are explanations of new capabilities.

Types

In Numeric there are two ways of referring to the type of an array, either by using a character code (one character string) or a type name. For example, one can specify a Numeric float as either Float, Float32, or 'f'. In fact Float and Float32 are simply module variables that have value 'f'.

In numarray, types are represented by type objects and not character codes. As with Numeric there is a module variable Float32, but now it represents an instance of a FloatingType class. For example, if x is a Float32 array

x.type()

will return a FloatingType instance associated with 32 bit floats (instead of using x.typecode() as is done in Numeric). Even so, comparisons for the new types objects should work with the character codes from Numeric.

So the following will work in numarray:

if x.typecode() == 'f':

Nevertheless, we recommend instead:

if x.type() == Float32

[all examples presume "from numarray import *" has been used instead of "import numarray"]

The advantage of the new scheme is that other kinds of tests become simpler. The type classes are heirarchical so one can easily test to see if the array is an integer array. For example:

if isinstance(x.type(), IntegralType):

or

if isinstance(x.type(), UnsignedIntegralType):

This is the type heirarchy


                                 NumericType
                                 |  |  |  |
                                /   |   \  \______________________
                    ___________/    |    \_________               |
                   |                |              |              |
              IntegralType     BooleanType    FloatingType   ComplexType
               |        |           |           |       |      |     |
              /          \        (Bool)   (Float32) (Float64) |     |
             /            \                                    |     |
            |              |                          (Complex64)
(Complex128)
UnsignedIntegralType   SignedIntegralType
   |         |          |       |       |
(UInt8)   (UInt16)   (Int8)  (Int16) (Int32)
   |         |          |       |       |
    \       /            \      |      /
 UnsignedIntegralType  SignedIntegralType
        |                       |
   UnsignedType            SignedType

In the above, parentheseis indicate instances of a type class. All of of the Int type classes inherit from Numeric type and one of SignedIntegralType or UnsignedIntegralType (multiple inheritance). Thus one can use isinstance() to see if an array is in a more general class of types.

Numarray defines a number of aliases for the above types. In particular:

               Aliases
Bool
Int8         '1', "i1", "Byte"
Int16        's', "i2", "Short"
Int32        'i', "i4", "Int"
UInt8        "u1", "UByte"
UInt16       "u2", "UShort"
Float32      'f', "f4", "Float"
Float64      'd', "f8", "Double"
Complex64    'F', "c8", "Complex"
Complex128   'D', "c16"

The aliases are generally accepted whereever a type class is when used as an argument for a type parameter or keyword. For example, the following are all equivalent:

x = array([2,3], 'f')
x = array([2,3], Float32)
x = array([2,3], "Float")
x = array([2,3], "f4")

The unsigned integer types have no corresponding type in Numeric, nor does Bool.

Type Coercion

In expressions involving only arrays, the normal coercion rules apply (i.e., the same as Numeric). However, the same rules do not apply to binary operations between arrays and Python scalars in certain cases. If the kind of number is the same for the array and scalar (e.g., both are integer types or both are float types), then the type of the output is determined by the precision of the array, not the scalar. Some examples will best illustrate:

Scalar type  *  Array type        Numeric result type    numarray result
type
   Int            Int16                Int32                    Int16
   Int            Int8                 Int32                    Int8
   Float          Int8                 Float64                  Float64
   Float          Float32              Float64                  Float32

The change in the rules was made so that it would be easy to preserve the precision of arrays in expressions involving scalars. Previous solutions with Numeric were either quite awkward (using a function to create a rank-0 array from a scalar with the desired type) or surprising (the savespace attribute, that never allowed type coercion). The problem arises because Python has a limited selection of scalar types. This appears to be the best solution though it admittedy may surprise some who are used to the classical type coercion model.

Another twist on type coercion appears when combining a signed int with an unsigned in. For example, combining an Int16 with an UInt16 results in an Int32 since neither type can hold the range of the other (we have not implemented UInt32 since we haven't implemented Int64)

Array Attributes

Contrary to early versions of numarray, array attributes are supported with versions of Python 2.2 and later. Earlier versions of Python may use get and set methods for array attributes (getshape(), setshape() for shape, etc.) But these methods are deprecated since numarray v0.4 and later will require Python 2.2 or later.

Private attributes:

Numarray arrays have lots of them (all preceded by underscores). Don't mess with them. Changing them in ways inconsistent with other attributes can result in numarray misbehaving (though we believe we now have modified numarray to prevent Python from crashing even in these cases.) Only those contributing to the underlying system code should access these attributes. Even for read-only purposes you should rely on the public methods and attributes (lest we change the details of the underlying attributes on you; you were warned!)

Other differences

Warning and error messages may have changed.

There are no doubt many other differences (mostly minor we hope) that we have not discovered (or have forgotten). Please let us know about them so we can properly document them.

New capabilities

Index Arrays:

Arrays supplied as arguments to subscripts have special meaning. If the array is of Bool type, then the indexing will be treated as the equivalent of the compress function. If the array is of an Integer type, then a take or put operation is implied. We will generalize the existing take and put as follows:

If ind1, ind2,...indN are index arrays whose values indicate the index into another array then

x[ind1, ind2]

forms a new array with the same shape as ind1, ind2 (they all must be broadcastable to the same shape) and values such:

result[i,j,k] = x[ind1[i,j,k], ind2[i,j,k]]

In this example, ind1, ind2 are index arrays with 3 dimensions (but they could have an arbitrary number of dimensions).

To illustrate with some specific examples:

>>> # simple index array example
>>> x = 2*arange(10)
>>> ind = array([3,6,2,4,4])
>>> x[ind]
array([ 6, 12,  4,  8,  8])

>>> # index a 2-d array
>>> x = arange(12)
>>> x = reshape(x,(3,4))
>>> x
array([[ 0,  1,  2,  3],
       [ 4,  5,  6,  7],
       [ 8,  9, 10, 11]])
>>> ind1 = array([2,1])
>>> ind2 = array([0,2])
>>> x[ind1, ind2]
array([8, 6])

>>> # multidimensional index arrays
>>> ind1 = array([[2,2],[1,0]])
>>> ind2 = array([[2,1],[0,1]])
>>> x[ind1, ind2]
array([[10,  9],
       [ 4,  1]])

>>> # Mindblowing combination of multidimensional index arrays with
>>> # partial indexing. Strap on your seatbelts.
>>> x[ind1]
array([[[ 8,  9, 10, 11],
   [ 8,  9, 10, 11]],

  [[ 4,  5,  6,  7],
   [ 0,  1,  2,  3]]])

Note that in this last example, each index in the single index array (ind1) is treated as though x were given only one index. For each of these 'single' indices, a 1-d array is returned, thus the combination of the 2 dimensions in the index array combined with the leftover dimension in the array being indexed produces a 3 dimensional array.

When using constants for some of the index positions, then the result uses that constant for all values. Slices and strides (at least initially) will not be permitted in the same subscript as index arrays. So

>>> x[ind1, 2]
array([[10, 10],
       [ 6,  2]])

would be legal, but

>>> x[ind1, 1:3]
Traceback (most recent call last):
[...]
    raise IndexError("Cannot mix arrays and slices as indices")
IndexError: Cannot mix arrays and slices as indices

would not be.

Similarly for assignment:

x[ind1, ind2, ind3] = values

will form a new array such that:

x[ind1[i,j,k], ind2[i,j,k], ind3[i,j,k]] = values[i,j,k]

The index arrays and the value array must be broadcast consistent. (As an example: ind1.shape()=(5,4), ind2.shape()=(5,), ind3.shape()=(1,4), and values.shape()=(1)).

# Index put example, using broadcasting and illustrating that Python
# integer sequences work as indices also.
>>> x = zeros((10,10))
>>> x[[2,5,6],array([0,1,9,3])[:,NewAxis]] = 111
>>> x
array([[  0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0],
  [  0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0],
  [111, 111,   0, 111,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0, 111],
  [  0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0],
  [  0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0],
  [111, 111,   0, 111,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0, 111],
  [111, 111,   0, 111,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0, 111],
  [  0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0],
  [  0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0],
  [  0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0,   0]])

If indices are repeated, the last value encountered will be stored. When index values are out of range they will be clipped to the appropriate range. That is to say, negative indices will not have the same meaning by default [This will change!]. Use of the equivalent take and put functions will allow other interpretations of the indices (raise exceptions for out of bounds indices, allow negative indices to work backwards as they do when used individually, or for indices to wrap around). The same behavior applies for functions such as choose and where. [We are planning to change indexing so that negative indices have the traditional Python interpretation]

>>> x = 2*arange(10)
>>> x[[0, 5, 100, 5]] = [1000, 1005, 1100, 2005]
>>> x
array([1000,    2,    4,    6,    8, 2005,   12,   14,   16, 1100])

Output arguments for Ufunc methods.

Reduce, accumulate, and outer accept an array as the ouput argument. Such arguments must be of the same type as the expected output and must be aligned and not byteswapped (some of these restrictions may be removed in the future).

Arbitrary types for Ufunc output arrays.

Like Numeric, numarray accepts an output array as an output argument for Ufuncs. Unlike Numeric, the array may have any type (automatic conversion is performed on the output).

tofile and fromfile capability

There is a fromfile function that creates an array directly from a file (based on the undocumented file method "readinto"). This avoids the need to read data in through a string. Likewise, there is a tofile method for arrays to do the reverse.

Examples:

x = fromfile("greatdata.dat", Float32, (100,100))

will create a Float32 100x100 data from the file greatdata.dat. If one wants to read an array offset into the file, open the file first, seek or otherwise move to the beginning of the data and then call the function.

f = open("greatdata.dat")
f.seek(2500)
x = from file(f, Float32, (100,100))

(2*x).tofile("doubledgreatdata.dat")

Likewise, tofile will work with file objects and one can write multiple arrays to a single output file that way.

Memory-mapped files:

It is possible to memory map a file and refer to its contents with Numarray

[Details to be provided later. See module docstrings for now.]

Record Arrays:

[Documentation forthcoming. See module docstrings for now.]

Character Arrays:

[Documentation forthcoming. See module docstrings for now.]

New Array properties:

It is possible to create an array where the values are intrinsically byteswapped. Normally we expect that this property will be set by a function that takes its data from a file and recognizes that the data are byteswapped and decides for whatever reason (e.g., memory mapping) that it should not byteswap the data in place. This is not a property we expect most users to be concerned with explicitly, but primarily for those that write software that creates arrays from memory mapped files or read only sources.

It is possible to create arrays with arbitrary byte offests and strides between elements. Such arrays may have data elements that are "nonaligned". As with byteswapping, we do not expect users to deal with this issue explicitly much; it is more for those that write functions that create record or other inhomogeneous, but regular, arrays.

Updated 2002 September 24

Copyright  | Help  | Printable Page