University of California
Lick Observatory Bulletin No. 1111
Third Catalog of Emission-Line Stars of the Orion Population
G.H. Herbig
Lick Observatory
Board of Studies in Astronomy and Astrophysics
University of California, Santa Cruz
and
Institute for Astronomy
University of Hawaii
and
K. Robbin Bell
Lick Observatory
Board of Studies in Astronomy and Astrophysics
University of California, Santa Cruz
(June 1988)
(This paper appears only in the Lick Observatory Bulletin series.
It will not be published in any journal)
ABSTRACT
This Catalog lists 735 pre-main sequence stars, members
of the Orion Population, that have been observed with slit
spectrographs or at equivalent resolution. It is intended
to replace the Second Catalog of Herbig and Rao (l972). It
gives accurate coordinates (many determined especially for
this Catalog), light ranges for known variables, UBVRI data
near maximum light, references to ultraviolet, X-ray and
radio observations and to light curves, value of v sin i and
the radial velocity when known, spectral type, equivalent
width of the H
emission line, references to spectral
reproductions or scans and spectroscopic studies and to
identification charts, and a classification (as a T Tau
star, FU Ori object, etc.)
I. Introduction, General Remarks
This is the third up-date of a listing of the pre-main
sequence stars, both certain and probable, that have
emission lines and that have been observed with slit
spectrographs or at comparable resolution. The first
(Herbig l962) contained l26 entries, the second (Herbig and
Rao l972: hereafter HRC) had 323, while the present Catalog
contains 735. Not only has the total number of stars
increased due to a higher level of observational activity
and the improvement of spectroscopic instrumentation, but
there is a greater variety of significant information to be
referenced: for example, there was no occasion in earlier
listings to mention v sini's, radial velocities, far-
ultraviolet, X-ray or radio-frequency data. The
classification scheme for pre-main sequence stars (described
below) has also been modified as the result of improved observational
information.
In order to accommodate such new information as well as
more accurate astrometric coordinates within a double page,
264-column format, it has been necessary to omit some
information that is relevant and would have been useful in
some cases:
- IRAS identifications are not included.
- Light curve classifications are not included,
partly because such traditional observations have
not kept pace with the volume of other information.
Instead, references are given to
sources where such information as exists may be
found, except in cases where rotational
modulation has been detected; such results are
given in the Remarks to Table 1.
- No references are given to polarization
information; however, that subject has recently
been surveyed very thoroughly by Bastien (l988).
- The "emission line intensity" classification of
the Second Catalog, a rather subjective quantity
but all that was available in l972, has been
replaced by the equivalent width of H
emission,
which is now readily determinable as the result
of the widespread use of linear, red-sensitive detectors.
- No references are given to proper motion information.
The numbers assigned by Herbig and Rao (l972), prefixed
HRC in the past, have been retained for those of the 323
stars of the Second Catalog that have survived subsequent
examination. Thus the new entries begin with 324 and extend
through 742. The ordering is strictly in order of right
ascension for l950.0. As the result of improved co-
ordinates, the original HRC ordering is sometimes altered.
It is suggested that Catalog entries be referred to by their
primary designation, which usually is in column 2. In
circumstances where the Catalog number must be used, it is
recommended that HRC now be replaced by HBC. Note also that
the letter n or an asterisk (*) which often follow the HBC
number are not part of that designation, but are separate
items of information.
It was suggested in the Second Catalog that many of the
variables in young clusters and associations that were not
then known to have line emission would turn out to have
bright H
or Ca II, H,K lines upon closer examination. This
has turned out to be so: many such stars are now included
as "weak-line T Tauris" (abbreviation: wt). A large number
of such stars have also been recognized as the result of X-
ray surveys of obscured regions, particularly the Taurus-
Auriga clouds. Walter and co-workers, who have done much of
this work, have called these objects "naked T Tauri stars",
or NTTS. It is our opinion that these do not constitute a
separate class of pre-main sequence stars, but are a quite
natural extension of the T Tauri class toward weaker line
emission since the cutoff of conventional T Tauri stars at
W(H
) ~ 5 Å was set only by the limitations of the early
objective-prism or -grating surveys. The existence of
substantial numbers of such stars was in fact to be expected
(Herbig l985) from the shape of the frequency distribution
of W(H
). We prefer the non-committal classification "wt"
for these stars as a group rather than NTTS, partly because
the latter implies a physical picture of the phenomenon that
is still speculative.
However, one kind of weak-emission star that has been
omitted from the Third Catalog are the rapid-rotating G- and
K-type dwarfs in young clusters, such as
Per and the
Pleiades, most of which have emission at H
. They have not
been included because they lie on or near the main sequence.
There are probably such stars in the field as well, and
consequently we have omitted objects such as W92/NGC 2264 (=
V642 Mon), Gliese l82 (= V1005 Ori), and any others that
appear to be BY Dra-like variables. On the other hand, we
have included many weak-emission G and K stars in the Orion
Nebula region and in NGC 2264, on the grounds that they lie
well above the main sequence and are therefore clearly pre-
main sequence objects.
The lower boundary of the Orion population, insofar as
it is represented in this Catalog, thus is not well defined.
Nor is it always apparent whether a late-type star having no
more than weak H
and Ca II emission is pre-main sequence or
not. This is a relatively recent problem. The sample of
emission objects that were turned up in the early H
surveys
were mostly classical T Tauri stars, where emission-line
criteria clearly provide the identification. Foreground dMe
stars were not detected, because such stars in the field and
in older aggregates like the Hyades rarely have W(H
)
greater than about 6 Å. But in younger clusters like the
Pleiades, emission H
has now been found in M dwarfs at
W(H
) values as large as l8 Å, although the most are less
than 12 Å (Stauffer and Hartmann 1986). When such stars
attract scrutiny as the consequence of some special
activity, such as variability or X-ray emission, unless
their luminosity is well enough known to locate them above
the main sequence, there is no obvious way to distinguish a
pre-main sequence star from its young main sequence
counterpart. It is possible that refinement of the lithium
abundance criterion might clarify this situation.
It must be stressed that the stars listed here have
been discovered by a variety of techniques, through searches
that have been concentrated in certain areas while other
regions have been almost neglected. Therefore, no one
should consider the Catalog as complete even to a fairly
modest limiting magnitude over any large fraction of the sky.
The Catalog references those sources and papers that
were available to us through March 1988. We shall be
grateful for any errors that are called to our attention.
II. The Catalog
Table 1 contains both real data as well as references
to published papers, the latter listed at the end of Table
1. In the following text, the numbers assigned to papers in
the Reference list are in [square brackets]. Within that
list, for journals which exist both in the original language
and in English translation, the English-language citation is
given first, followed by the original in brackets (thus:
Sov.Astr.-A.J. 7, 2l9 [7, 398]).
Table 1 is organized as follows.
Column
- HBC The running number is followed by n when the star
is itself involved in, or illuminates bright
nebulosity. An asterisk (*) indicates that a Remark
follows the Table.
- Star This is the preferred designation of the object;
if a variable star name has been assigned that is
always given preference. If the preferred name is too
long, a > symbol indicates that it follows in col. 3.
- Other designation: The conventional designations (AS,
LkH
, Haro ...) are explained in HRC. We have found
it necessary in some cases to expand the prefix
system, usually abbreviating discoverers' names by
two-letter symbols rather than one to avoid confusion
with variable star designations (thus: CoKu for Cohen
and Kuhi). We have also retained the discoverer's
name for an object wherever possible, rather than
substituting what might seem a more rational
designation (thus: P2441/c for the companion of
P2441, rather than P2441 B). The prefixes used in
cols. 2, 3 are as follows:
CD Cape Photographic Durchmusterung
CoD Cordoba Durchmusterung
CoKu Cohen and Kuhi [93]
Eggen [125]
Elias Tau-Aur [128]; Oph [127]; IC 5146 [126]
FK Feigelson and Kriss [132]
GlPe Glass and Penston [157]
GM Gyulbudaghian and Magakyan [177]
HaGr Hartigan and Graham [186]
He 3- Henize [195]
HH Herbig [211] and later publications by a variety of authors.
HJ Herbig and Jones [218]
HJM Hyland, Jones and Mitchell [238]
HM Henize and Mendoza [196]
JH Jones and Herbig [250]
Kn Knacke et al. [274]
LkCa Herbig, Vrba and Rydgren [219]
LZK Liu, Zhang and Kimura [315]
MacC MacConnell 1968: Cep-Cas; 1981: Pup
MaRy Marraco and Rydgren [323]
MC Cohen [90]
NTTS Walter et al. [506]
OgHa Ogura and Hasegawa [355]
P 4 digits: Parenago [359]
1 digit: Mundt et al. [344]
Par Parsamian [360]
PC Parsamian and Chavira [363]: PC numbers have been assigned
to all the confirmed Tonantzintla discoveries in the Orion
Nebula region, but Table 1 gives only those that have no
Haro 6- designations.
PH Pettersson [370, 371]
PP Parsamian and Petrossian [362]
ROX Montmerle et al [332]
RNO Cohen [85]
S Sonneberg variable star
San Sanduleak [417]
SS 1 Sanduleak and Stephenson [419a]
SS 2 Stephenson and Sanduleak [444a]
SSS Strom, Strom and Stocke [450]
SSV Strom, Vrba and Strom [455]
St Stephenson [444]
Sz Schwartz [426]
TH The: see Table 3
vBH van den Bergh and Herbst [482]
VSB Vasilevskis, Sanders and Balz [485]
W Walker, NGC 2264 [494]; IC 5146 [495]
Wa Walter [502]
WK Walter and Kuhi [504]
Wray Wackerling 1970
- Right Ascension
- Declination
- The coordinates indicated by B in col. 6 were
determined by one of us (KRB) with the Lick Automatic
Measuring Machine on yellow (in most cases) plates of
the Lick astrometric program. Usually 15 to 20
reference stars from the AGK3, with proper motions
applied, were used. The epoch (minus 1900), rounded
off to the nearest year, follows the B. The
indicated by Aw in col. 6 were originally
measured by C.A. Wirtanen, from blue plates of the
Lick program, for the HRC. The epoch of those
coordinates is approximately 1950. We do not regard
either B or Aw coordinates to be of astrometric
quality. Coordinates drawn from other sources are
referenced accordingly. Those brought forward to
1950.0 have not had proper motions applied, so remain
at their original epoch.
- These two columns contain the
- Galactic coordinates in the lII, bII system
- These two columns contain the
- Photometric range if the star is a known
variable, expressed in the magnitude system indicated.
Values taken from the 4th edition (1985, 1987) of the
General Catalogue of Variable Stars, or recent
Supplements, are indicated by a C. (Note that the
conventional practice is followed in that < means
"fainter than".) Stars believed to be variable are
indicated var. A number of stars not known to be
variable have their mean, or estimated magnitudes in
these columns if that magnitude is not visual or in
the Johnson V system; otherwise that value is in col.
11.
- V
- B-V
- U-B photometry: for stars observed
more than once, unlike HRC practice (where mean values
were given regardless of phase) these columns contain
the values observed when the star was brightest in V
and a full set of UBVRI magnitudes were measured at
essentially the same time. In some cases, the colors
show a substantial scatter at the same value of V;
such colors are marked with a v. For those stars
where there is only a small scatter about a mean V, or
where a small-range cyclic variation is superposed
upon irregular activity, mean rather than maximum-V
values are tabulated; such stars have an m following
their V magnitude.
- Photometric references: the first number is the
source from which the tabulated values are taken.
Additional sources of UBV data follow. For stars
having an extensive photometric history, a * means
that details are in a Remark to Table 1. An hrc
means that some information given in the Second
Catalog is not repeated here.
- The HBC number again.
- V-R
- V-I values, usually obtained simultaneously
(i.e., at maximum V) with the UBV data of cols. 11-13;
this is so if the first reference in col. 19 is the
same as the first in col. 14.
- A single letter (J, C) shows whether the R, I
values are on the Johnson or Cousins system. An i
indicates an instrumental (r,i) system; conversion
relations for the photometry by Rydgren and co-workers
are given in [407].
- References to the V-R, V-I data, as described for
col. 14.
- References for infrared magnitudes,
spectrophotometry and spectroscopy. However, low
angular resolution far-infrared observations are not
usually cited.
- UV, X-ray references: these usually refer to IUE
spectroscopy and to X-ray detections from the Einstein
survey.
- Radio references are to VLA observations or to
detection of the star by some other means. No attempt
is made to cite radio frequency molecular line
observations of the cloud in the general neighborhood
of the star.
- Light curve: references to photometric studies
published since HRC. An hrc means that significant
references in the Second Catalog are not repeated
here.
- v sini, the projected axial rotational velocity,
given only to the nearest km/s. If no radial velocity
value appears in col. 25, then that reference is to
the source of the v sini; if a value for the radial
velocity is given, then the second reference is
(usually) the source of the v sini.
- These two columns contain
- Radial velocity (heliocentric, in km/s), quality,
and reference. In all cases, these velocities are
from the absorption line spectrum. Velocities
obtained with modern equipment usually replace those
obtained at low dispersion by the early observers.
The quality letter (a, b, c) expresses our judgment as
to the uncertainty of the quoted velocity: a
indicates a velocity of the highest quality, with an
uncertainty of 1-2 km/s; b means a value with an
uncertainty of 3-5 km/s; and c a velocity of still
lower accuracy. For some stars we have not given the
published velocities at all. Comments on several
special objects (*) appear in the Remarks.
- Spectral type. With the growing employment of
red-sensitive detectors, spectral types determined
since the HRC have increasingly been dependent upon
criteria in the region longward of about 5000 Å.
However, it is apparent that significant differences
exist in T Tauri spectra between such types and those
assigned by the early observers of the 4000-4500 Å
region ([498] and Appenzeller 1985). Furthermore, it
is not clear whether the spectral types of such stars
change during their light variations or at other
times. Therefore, it may not be possible to assign a
MK type to a T Tauri star without further
qualification. We have not faced up to such issues:
the types given here for those stars for which more
than a single classification is available are either
compromise values (usually indicated by :), or in case
of conflict that value which seems most reasonable to
us. No indication is given of the spectral region in
which the type was assigned. Several special cases
are explained in the Remarks. Many of the types in
HRC were based on unwidened, very low-dispersion,
often underexposed Lick spectrograms; in all but a
very few cases, those classifications have here been
disregarded. The conventions in col. 27 are as in
HRC: type K7, M0 means either K7 or M0, while K7-M0
means a type between K7 and M0. If the Li I 6707 Å
line has been detected in absorption, the type is
followed by (Li). The very fact that the star is
included in this Catalog indicates that emission lines
have been detected (except in a very few special
cases, all explained in the Remarks), so the suffix e
for emission is not printed for types G and later in
col. 27 although it properly is a part of the
classification; the e should be added if these types
are quoted. However, in order to avoid possible
misunderstanding, that e has been included for all the
B, A and F types where line emission is present. An
hrc means that some significant information either in
the Second Catalog, or referenced there, is not
repeated.
- References to the source of the type quoted.
Information in col. 27 which does not appear in the
papers cited is usually from unpublished Lick
material; a blank reference has that specific
meaning.
- These two columns contain
- Equivalent width of H
emission (in Å): These
are from the original sources, and are often mean
values. Different observers at different times
sometimes quote very different results and it is often
uncertain whether this represents real variation or is
an instrumental effect; when real variations seem to
be present, the mean is given followed by a v. A
number of cases where the W(H
) value from slit
spectroscopy seems incompatible with the fact of
detection of H
on an objective- prism plate are
mentioned in the Remarks. A hk in col. 29 means that
there is no information on H
, but that emission is
present in the H,K lines of Ca II. A pr means that
H
emission has been detected, but that no value for the
equivalent width is available. An abs means that
H
is in absorption. An em means that unspecified
emission lines have been observed [238]. A * means
that there is a Remark.
- Spectrum references show where the spectrum is
reproduced (either photographically or as a scan), or
the spectrum is described or discussed.
- Type gives our judgment as to which group
the star belongs. The abbreviations are:
tt T Tauri star
wt weak-line T Tauri star, usually having W(H
) less
than about 10 Å and no other emission in the
optical region except Ca II H,K. This includes
most of the so-called "Naked T Tauri Stars".
su A star like SU Aur: type late F to K, weak
emission at H
and Ca II, very broad absorption
lines (v sini > 50 km/s), and relatively high
luminosity.
ae An Ae or Be star such as those described in [203].
fu A star of the type of FU Ori.
? Type uncertain: the information is adequate, but
the object does not fit into any established
group; these stars are usually described in more
detail in the Remarks. Also, one of the original
criteria for membership in the Ae, Be group was
that the star illuminate bright nebulosity, but
now a number of irregular variables are known
which are photometrically and spectroscopically
similar but are not nebulous or associated with
obvious obscuration (UX Ori, WW Vul, SV Cep, BO
Cep, ...). These questionable objects are also
marked ? , or in some cases a?, in the Table.
-- A blank means that the observational information
is inadequate.
- Reference to an identification chart or photograph.
- The name of the bright nebulosity, dark cloud,
cluster, association, or other object with which the
star is associated or projected upon. A number of
southern cloud complexes are designated by the
abbreviations used by Schwartz [426]; note that these
are not the T-association designations of Kholopov
(1959) or the R associations of Herbst (1975).
The prefixes used are:
B Barnard (1927)
FS Feitzinger and Stuwe (1984)
Gum the Gum Nebula region
L Lynds (1962)
Ori the Orion Nebula region
Sh Sharpless (1959)
Following the main Table are two shorter lists which
may be found useful, of the Lick LH
and LkH
assignments,
and of the H
star discoveries made at Bosscha Observatory
by The and co-workers.
We are greatly indebted to A. Klemola for his help with
the astrometric measurements, to B.F. Jones for unpublished
coordinates and other assistance, and to many colleagues for
preprints and unpublished information. We are also very
grateful for partial support by the National Science
Foundation, most recently under Grant NSF AST82-03115, for
much of the observational work at Lick Observatory that is
included here as well as for the preparation of the Catalog
itself.
REFERENCES
Appenzeller, I. 1985, Phys. Scripta T11, 76.
Barnard, E.E. 1927, Carnegie Inst. Wash. Publ. 247.
Bastien, P. 1988, in Polarized Radiation of Circumstellar
Origin (Vatican Conference, June 1987).
Feitzinger, J.V. and Stuwe, J.A. 1984, Astr.Ap. Suppl. 58, 365.
Herbig, G.H. 1962, Adv.Astr.Ap. 1, 47.
Herbig, G.H. and Rao, N.K. 1972, Ap.J. 174, 401.
Herbig, G.H. 1985, Birth and Infancy of Stars, ed. R.
Lucas, A. Omont, and R. Stora (North Holland), p. 535.
Herbst, W. 1975, Astr.J. 80, 503.
Kholopov, P.N. 1959, Sov.Astr.-A.J. 3, 291, 425 [36, 295, 434].
Lynds, B.T. 1962, Ap.J. Suppl. 7, 1.
MacConnell, D.J. 1968, Ap.J. Suppl. 16, 275 (Cep-Cas).
MacConnell, D.J. 1981, Astr.Ap. Suppl. 44, 387 (Pup).
Stauffer, J.R. and Hartmann, L.W. 1986, Ap.J.Suppl. 6l, 531.
Wackerling, L.R. 1970, Mem. R.A.S. 73, 153.
The original HTML version of the Herbig-Bell Catalog
was prepared by Karen Strom.
Maintained by Alan D. Welty
(welty@stsci.edu)
Last update: 1999 February 19