<?xml version="1.0" encoding="ISO-8859-1"?>

<HSTProposal
   Phase1ID="923"
   Phase2ID="12848"
   Phase="Phase I"
   AptVersion="Version 20.0.2 ">
   <!--**********************************************************************************************************************-->
   <!--This file is automatically generated and should not be edited by hand. Editing this file directly is at your own risk.-->
   <!--**********************************************************************************************************************-->
   <!--APT Output Product-->
   <!---->
   <!--APT Version: Version 20.0.2 -->
   <!--Date: Fri Feb 24 23:40:45 GMT 2012-->
   
   <ToolData>
      
      <ToolDataItem
         Key="SubmissionData">
         
         <SubmissionData
            AptVersion="Version 20.0.2 "
            SubmissionCounter="1"
            SubmissionSuccessCounter="0"
            HasErrors="false"
            Cycle="20"
            IncludeSysInfo="true"
            NotificationAddress="robert.h.rubin@nasa.gov"
            AssignedID="923">
            
            <SystemInformation
               os.arch="x86_64"
               os.name="Mac OS X"
               os.version="10.6.8"
               java.version="1.6.0_29"
               Runtime.maxMemory="1295"
               linux.distribution="not available"
               linux.version="not available" />
            
            <SubmissionComments />
            
            <SubmissionLog>Assigned ID: 923
----- Attempting Submission 1 (Fri Feb 24 23:40:45 GMT 2012) -----</SubmissionLog>
            
            <DiagnosticJustification />
         </SubmissionData>
      </ToolDataItem>
   </ToolData>
   
   <ProposalInformation
      Category="AR"
      PureParallelProposal="false"
      Cycle="20"
      STScIEditNumber="0">
      
      <Title>Cospatial [O III] emission with Herschel and Hubble to address the nebular abundance discrepancy problem</Title>
      
      <Abstract>There exist planetary nebulae (PNe) whose heavy element C, N, O, and Ne abundances as derived from optical recombination lines (ORLs) are a factor more than ~5 higher than those derived from the traditional method based on collisionally excited lines (CELs). This ratio is called the abundance discrepancy factor (adf). A promising proposition to explain this long-standing nebular abundance problem posits that these nebulae contain (at least) two distinct regions - one of "normal" electron temperature, Te (~10000 K) and chemical composition (~solar) and another of very low Te (&lt; 1000) that is H-deficient, thus having high metal abundances relative to H. The latter component emits strong heavy element ORLs and IR fine-structure (FS) CELs, but essentially no optical/UV CELs. Efforts to directly detect these inclusions in PNe have been unsuccessful to date. However, there is mounting circumstantial evidence for their existence, such as presented in our recent paper that modeled the high-adf PN NGC 6153 using a 3-D photoionization code. The models that included the low Te, H-deficient knots fit most observations far better than did those models without the clumps. It has been shown that the adf varies with position in a PN and is highest close to the central star. The very low Te inclusions must be cooled predominantly by FS mid-IR lines. We propose to use HST archival images to derive [O III] 5007 A flux maps to compare with the [O III] 88 micron fluxes from our Herschel observations of four PNe - NGC 2392, NGC 2440, NGC 6720 and NGC 7009 - all on the largest adf list, to find if the IR line flux relative to the cospatial optical forbidden line flux peaks where the adf peaks.</Abstract>
      
      <PrincipalInvestigator
         Honorific="Dr."
         FirstName="Robert"
         MiddleInitial="H."
         LastName="Rubin"
         ESAMember="false"
         UniqueID="2226"
         Institution="NASA Ames Research Center"
         Country="USA"
         State="CA" />
      
      <CoInvestigator
         Honorific="Dr."
         FirstName="Sean"
         LastName="Colgan"
         ESAMember="false"
         UniqueID="4381"
         Institution="NASA Ames Research Center"
         Country="USA"
         State="CA"
         AdminUSPI="false"
         Contact="false" />
      
      <CoInvestigator
         Honorific="Dr."
         FirstName="A.G.G.M."
         LastName="Tielens"
         ESAMember="true"
         UniqueID="4844"
         Institution="Space Research Organization Netherlands"
         Country="NLD"
         AdminUSPI="false"
         Contact="false" />
      
      <CoInvestigator
         Honorific="Dr."
         FirstName="Yiannis"
         MiddleInitial="G."
         LastName="Tsamis"
         ESAMember="true"
         UniqueID="8338"
         Institution="European Southern Observatory - Germany"
         Country="DEU"
         AdminUSPI="false"
         Contact="false" />
      
      <Questions>
         
         <Phase2Questions>
            
            <ObservingDescription />
            
            <RealtimeJustification />
            
            <CalibrationJustification />
            
            <AdditionalComments />
         </Phase2Questions>
      </Questions>
      
      <Orbits
         ThisCycle2GyroPrimary="1"
         ThisCycle2GyroParallel="0"
         NextCycle2GyroPrimary="0"
         NextCycle2GyroParallel="0"
         AfterNext2GyroPrimary="0"
         AfterNext2GyroParallel="0" />
      
      <Phase1ProposalInformation
         TotalTargets="1"
         Attachment="/Users/robertrubin/HST/CYCLE20/rr.pdf">
         
         <ScientificCategory>ISM AND CIRCUMSTELLAR MATTER</ScientificCategory>
         
         <ScientificKeyword1
            Keyword="Chemical Abundances" />
         
         <ScientificKeyword2
            Keyword="Interstellar And Intergalactic Medium" />
         
         <ScientificKeyword3
            Keyword="Planetary Nebulae" />
         
         <ProprietaryPeriod>12</ProprietaryPeriod>
         
         <Budget>Small</Budget>
         
         <CalibProp>false</CalibProp>
         
         <ChandraCoord>0.0</ChandraCoord>
         
         <NOAONights>0.0</NOAONights>
         
         <Treasury>false</Treasury>
         
         <MultiCycleTreasury>false</MultiCycleTreasury>
         
         <Theory>false</Theory>
         
         <LargeProgram>false</LargeProgram>
      </Phase1ProposalInformation>
      
      <Phase2ProposalInformation
         PCFlag="false">
         
         <Availability>SUPPORTED</Availability>
      </Phase2ProposalInformation>
   </ProposalInformation>
   
   <Targets />
   
   <Observations />
   
   <Datasets>
      
      <Dataset
         Instrument="WFPC2"
         Number="1"
         NumberOfDatasets="6"
         RetrievalMethod="FTP"
         RetrievalPlan="over a weekend" />
      
      <Dataset
         Instrument="WFC3"
         Number="2"
         NumberOfDatasets="1"
         RetrievalMethod="FTP"
         RetrievalPlan="over a weekend" />
   </Datasets>
   
   <Patterns />
   
   <Visits />
</HSTProposal>


