<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>

<HSTProposal
   Phase1ID="184"
   Phase2ID="16140"
   Phase="Phase I"
   AptVersion="Version 2020.1.2  ">
   <!--**********************************************************************************************************************-->
   <!--This file is automatically generated and should not be edited by hand. Editing this file directly is at your own risk.-->
   <!--**********************************************************************************************************************-->
   <!--APT Output Product-->
   <!---->
   <!--APT Version: Version 2020.1.2  -->
   <!--Date: Fri Mar 06 21:41:55 GMT 2020-->
   
   <ToolData>
      
      <ToolDataItem
         Key="SubmissionData">
         
         <SubmissionData
            AptVersion="Version 2020.1.2  "
            SubmissionMode=""
            SubmissionCounter="2"
            SubmissionSuccessCounter="1"
            HasErrors="false"
            Cycle="28"
            IncludeSysInfo="true"
            NotificationAddress="clochhaas@stsci.edu"
            AssignedID="184">
            
            <SystemInformation
               os.arch="x86_64"
               os.name="Mac OS X"
               os.version="10.14.6"
               java.version="10.0.1"
               Runtime.maxMemory="5734"
               linux.distribution="not available"
               linux.version="not available"
               screens="1440x900,2560x1440" />
            
            <ErrorText />
            
            <SubmissionComments />
            
            <SubmissionCommentsCheckSum>0</SubmissionCommentsCheckSum>
            
            <SubmissionLog>Assigned ID: 184

----- Attempting Submission 1 (Wed Mar 04 21:19:33 GMT 2020) -----
HST Phase I Proposal 184  successfully submitted.
Receipt: # 184-1

----- Attempting Submission 2 (Fri Mar 06 21:41:55 GMT 2020) -----</SubmissionLog>
            
            <DiagnosticJustification />
         </SubmissionData>
      </ToolDataItem>
   </ToolData>
   
   <ProposalInformation
      Category="AR"
      SnapPriority="Normal Priority"
      PureParallelProposal="false"
      Cycle="28"
      STScIEditNumber="0">
      
      <Title>What Holds Up the CGM?</Title>
      
      <Abstract>The standard paradigm of galaxy evolution assumes the circumgalactic medium (CGM) is primarily composed of hot gas in hydrostatic equilibrium (HSE) within the gravitational potential of the galaxy's halo. However, COS observations challenge this paradigm by finding a larger quantity of cool gas in the CGM of L* galaxies than expected. Recent analytic models that reconcile the cool gas mass budgets with the assumption of HSE are in tension with CGM simulations, which show large deviations from HSE driven by inflows, outflows, and turbulence. A successful model of the CGM will thus need to account for the contribution of these motions, not just gas pressure, to its long-term dynamic equilibrium. We propose developing a new CGM support model based on quantified contributions of outflows, accretion, and turbulence to the overall support of gas, rather than imposing HSE. We will use the high-resolution Figuring Out Gas &amp; Galaxies in Enzo (FOGGIE) zoom-in simulations to identify spatially distinct regions of the CGM (e.g. outflows vs. accretion) and characterize turbulent motions and rotation. We will determine how the dynamical equilibrium of CGM gas depends on physical properties of galaxies, including outflow rate, accretion rate, redshift, and halo mass. We will perform a controlled experiment by repeating the full analysis on a restarted FOGGIE run with elevated feedback. For all runs we will use synthetic absorption spectra to explore how the flows that hold up the CGM against gravity are reflected in the observations. The new model and synthetic data together will be directly applicable to the interpretation of past and future COS quasar absorption line spectra.</Abstract>
      
      <PrincipalInvestigator
         Honorific="Dr."
         FirstName="Cassandra"
         LastName="Lochhaas"
         ESAMember="false"
         CSAMember="false"
         Retired="false"
         UniqueID="28706"
         Institution="Space Telescope Science Institute"
         Country="USA"
         State="MD"
         Contact="true" />
      
      <CoInvestigator
         Honorific="Dr."
         FirstName="Jason"
         LastName="Tumlinson"
         ESAMember="false"
         CSAMember="false"
         Retired="false"
         UniqueID="6250"
         Institution="Space Telescope Science Institute"
         Country="USA"
         State="MD"
         Contact="false"
         AdminUSPI="false" />
      
      <CoInvestigator
         Honorific="Dr."
         FirstName="Molly"
         LastName="Peeples"
         ESAMember="false"
         CSAMember="false"
         Retired="false"
         UniqueID="12612"
         Institution="Space Telescope Science Institute"
         Country="USA"
         State="MD"
         Contact="false"
         AdminUSPI="false" />
      
      <CoInvestigator
         Honorific="Prof."
         FirstName="Brian"
         MiddleInitial="W."
         LastName="O'Shea"
         ESAMember="false"
         CSAMember="false"
         Retired="false"
         UniqueID="13182"
         Institution="Michigan State University"
         Country="USA"
         State="MI"
         Contact="false"
         AdminUSPI="false" />
      
      <CoInvestigator
         Honorific="Dr."
         FirstName="Yong"
         LastName="Zheng"
         ESAMember="false"
         CSAMember="false"
         Retired="false"
         UniqueID="17485"
         Institution="University of California - Berkeley"
         Country="USA"
         State="CA"
         Contact="false"
         AdminUSPI="false" />
      
      <Questions>
         
         <Phase2Questions />
      </Questions>
      
      <TeamExpertise>PI Lochhaas has experience analyzing CGM simulations, as shown by Lochhaas et al. (2020), in which a similar analysis was carried out as is proposed. Co-Is Peeples, Tumlinson, and O'Shea are the co-PIs of the FOGGIE suite of simulations and thus have experience in both running and analyzing the FOGGIE simulations. Co-I Zheng has experience analyzing the FOGGIE simulations and in producing synthetic observations, as shown by Zheng et al. (2020) - FOGGIE III. The Mocky Way: Investigating Biases in Observing the Milky Way's Circumgalactic Medium (arXiv:2001.07736).</TeamExpertise>
      
      <Phase1ProposalInformation
         Attachment="/Users/clochhaas/Documents/Applications/HST Theory Proposal 2020/phase1-AR.pdf">
         
         <ScientificCategory>Intergalactic Medium and the Circumgalactic Medium</ScientificCategory>
         
         <ScientificKeyword1
            Keyword="Astronomical Models" />
         
         <ScientificKeyword2
            Keyword="Astronomical Simulations" />
         
         <ScientificKeyword3
            Keyword="Circumgalactic Medium" />
         
         <ScientificKeyword4
            Keyword="Cooling Flows" />
         
         <ScientificKeyword5
            Keyword="Metal Line Absorbers" />
         
         <ProprietaryPeriod
            Default="true">0</ProprietaryPeriod>
         
         <Budget>Regular</Budget>
         
         <CalibProp>false</CalibProp>
         
         <FundamentalPhysics>false</FundamentalPhysics>
         
         <UvInit>false</UvInit>
         
         <Theory>true</Theory>
         
         <CloudComputing>false</CloudComputing>
      </Phase1ProposalInformation>
      
      <Phase2ProposalInformation
         PCFlag="false">
         
         <Availability>SUPPORTED</Availability>
      </Phase2ProposalInformation>
   </ProposalInformation>
   
   <Patterns />
   
   <Visits />
</HSTProposal>
